
The 2026 midterms felt different from where I sit, for two reasons. One friend’s vote finally counted. And for the first time in my adult life, my parents’ generation turned up and didn’t get to decide.
The morning after the US midterms I sent a one-word message to a friend in Austin: “Congratulations!!!!”
Texas had just elected James Talarico to the US Senate and Gina Hinojosa as governor, the first Democrats to win statewide there since 1994. The Associated Press called both races; its count as of 11 November (NZ time), with an estimated 99% of votes in, had Talarico on 55.1% and Hinojosa on 52.8%.
Her reply:
Thank you so much! I’ve always felt my vote didn’t count and last night it actually felt like it did!
I forwarded that to a mutual friend in California (the three of us used to work together). She wrote back:
Oh that’s amazing. And what America is SUPPOSED to feel like! So grateful the electoral college has nothing to do with midterms!
I’ve been turning those two messages over for nearly a fortnight. There are two stories in them. The first is about a vote that counted. The second, which I think is the bigger one, is about who did the deciding.
A lever connected to nothing
The pedant’s objection first, because I can hear it coming. The electoral college has never had anything to do with midterms. Texas Democrats managed to lose every statewide race for thirty-two years on a straight popular vote, no electors required. So was my friend in California wrong?
I don’t think so. I think she was describing what a system teaches the people who use it.
Every four years, the loudest election in the country tells a Democrat in Austin that her ballot is decorative. It tells a Republican in Fresno exactly the same thing. (In 2020, more Californians voted for Donald Trump than Texans did. Roughly six million votes, and not one of them moved anything.) Run that lesson for a generation and people learn it. Worse, the lesson doesn’t stay in its lane. If the vote that gets all the attention is a lever connected to nothing, why would you trust the other levers? Texas Democrats argued for years that theirs was less a Republican state than a non-voting one.
I spent a good part of my career involved with UX, and this is a pattern any designer would recognise. When an interface ignores input, people stop pressing the button. You don’t blame the user for that. You blame the design.
A statewide midterm race is the opposite design. One person, one vote, one pile. No winner-take-all slate of electors. No district lines either: you can’t gerrymander a governor’s or a senator’s race. A vote in Austin weighs exactly what a vote in Lubbock weighs, and for once the pile came out the other way.
The electoral college has its defenders, and their case deserves a sentence: it forces candidates to build coalitions across regions, and it stops the big cities from simply outvoting everyone else. I’d take that more seriously if the current arrangement didn’t already hand the whole contest to half a dozen battleground states while everyone else watches.
I live in a country that changed its voting system in the 1990s for more or less this reason: too many people had worked out that their vote was scenery. Under MMP the feeling my friend had on election night is the ordinary one.
Thirty years of being outvoted
But there is a second way to feel that your vote doesn’t count, and it has nothing to do with electors. It’s the feeling of doing the sums and realising you are always going to be outnumbered by the same people.
Three American presidents were born in the summer of 1946. Bill Clinton took office in 1993; Donald Trump, who turned 80 this year, is still in it. For most of the years in between, the country has been run by people who came of age before the moon landing.
That isn’t a conspiracy. It’s arithmetic, and it comes in two parts. The Boomers were an enormous cohort, and they vote. In the 2022 midterms voters over 65 were about 24% of eligible citizens and 30% of the people who actually cast a ballot; under-30s were nearly 20% of the eligible and under 12% of the voters. Midterms are where the gap is widest. The over-65 share of the midterm electorate has nearly doubled since 2006.
To be fair to my parents’ generation: they didn’t cheat. They showed up, every time, which is precisely what we tell people to do. But the effect on everyone younger has been thirty years of politics pitched at somebody else. Housing as an asset to protect, not a place to live. Climate as a problem for later. A retirement system defended to the last comma by people already drawing on it, while the people paying into it were told to be realistic. You can hold all of that against no individual Boomer and still be thoroughly sick of the maths.
Generation X learnt to shrug. Millennials learnt to make jokes about avocado toast. Gen Z, as far as I can tell, skipped both and went straight to fury.
And then the maths changed
Here is what happened on 3 November. The Boomers did not stay home. Voters 65 and over were 36% of the electorate, their biggest share of a midterm in at least twenty years.
They split 50 to 49.
Under-45s, by the same exit poll, went 66 to 31.
Read those three numbers again, because that is the whole story. The largest, most reliable voting bloc in the country turned up in force and cancelled itself out. The result was settled by everyone else.
It showed in the faces. Watching the coverage, I kept noticing how many of the people at the podiums were in their late thirties and early forties. Talarico is 37. Future Caucus counts 97 Gen Z and millennial winners headed to Congress, and more than a third of this year’s candidates were under 45, up from a quarter in 2024.
And the clearing-out began before November, on the left. Seven sitting House Democrats lost their primaries, which ties the worst year for the party’s incumbents this century, and five of the seven were past retirement age. John Larson, 78 and nearly three decades in Congress, went down by more than twenty points to a 47-year-old. In Denver, a fifteen-term incumbent lost to Melat Kiros, who is 29. Younger voters didn’t only vote against the other side’s elders. They started with their own.
So no, this was not an election without Boomers. It was something more interesting: an election with all of them in the room, where they weren’t the ones deciding. This is what a post-Boomer election looks like.
Vibe check: swing or shift?
I should be suspicious of my own excitement here, so let me steel-man the other side.
Midterms nearly always punish the president’s party. Six in ten voters disapproved of Trump and the economy was the top issue, which is the recipe for an ordinary backlash. The young voters who drove the result are the same ones who moved towards Trump two years ago; people who work with them say plainly that their support is on loan and depends on results. And under-30s were still only about one voter in ten. On that reading this was a mood, and moods pass.
I think that reading is right about the votes and wrong about the people.
Votes swing. That’s what they’re for. But a 37-year-old senator doesn’t swing back into being 78. Nearly a hundred members of Congress under 45 now have incumbency, the same advantage that kept their predecessors in place for decades. The primaries weren’t a reaction to Trump at all; they were one party’s voters retiring their own leadership. And underneath all of it the arithmetic keeps moving: by 2028, Gen Z and millennials are projected to be more than half the electorate.
So my vibe check is this. The margin was a swing, and it can swing back. The changing of the guard was a shift, and it can’t. Whoever wins the next one, on whichever side, will have to win it from people under 50.
A caveat or two, in fairness. Ed Markey is 80 and won his primary in a canter. Nearly every Democratic incumbent faced a younger challenger and most survived. And the governor-elect of Texas is 52, which makes her Generation X, a cohort so used to being skipped that nobody thought to put us in the headline.
Someone who looks like her
Which brings me back to Austin.
My friend is a middle-aged woman who has voted in Texas for years on the understanding that it made no difference. This month her vote went into a pile that won. And the person at the top of that pile is a 52-year-old woman from Austin.
That is two kinds of representation arriving on the same night. The arithmetic kind, where your vote is counted and the count matters. And the recognisable kind, where you look at who won and see somebody whose life resembles yours, not your parents’.
Right! Today I want to be able to vote and have it count.
It’s an ordinary thing to want. The trick now is to make it unremarkable.
Sources
- Associated Press (carried by CultureMap Austin): Talarico, Hinojosa flip Texas in historic 2026 election sweep; vote percentages are from AP’s results count as of 11 November 2026, NZ time
- Texas Tribune: Democrats stun in Texas 2026 midterm elections (live blog)
- Time: Talarico wins Texas Senate race, first Democrat to win statewide in more than 30 years
- California Secretary of State: 2020 general election, presidential results
- Texas Secretary of State: presidential election results
- Electoral Commission (NZ): A Royal Commission and two referendums
- Newsweek: The presidents of 1946
- US Census Bureau: 2022 Congressional Election Voting Report
- Carlos Yordan: The Generational Divide, how Americans voted in the 2026 midterms
- NBC News: 2026 national exit polls
- Fast Company: Congress is getting a lot younger
- The Hill: Midterm results deliver ‘youth quake’ to American politics
- Axios: Older House Democrats walloped by midterms anti-establishment revolt
- Washington Examiner: Democratic incumbents fall in primaries as voters demand generational shift
- NPR: Melat Kiros becomes the first Gen Z woman elected to Congress
- NPR: How Gen Z voters helped fuel a blue wave for Democrats
- Political.org: The anti-incumbent wave of 2026
- Election coverage video (YouTube)
Leave a Reply